The autonomy ladder
The autonomy ladder is the five levels, 0 to 4, that describe how much of a workflow agents do on their own. This page defines each level, carries one example through all five and gives the rules for moving up and down.
The five levels
Section titled “The five levels”| Level | Name | Who does the work |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Recorded | People do the work. The software captures it as structured data. |
| 1 | Assisted | People do the work. Agents draft, summarize and answer questions. |
| 2 | Prepared | Agents prepare each transaction in full. A person approves every one. |
| 3 | Supervised | Agents complete the work within set limits. People handle exceptions and spot-check. |
| 4 | Autonomous | Agents run the workflow end to end. People set policy and audit. |
A level belongs to a workflow, not to an agent and not to your company as a whole. Sales order entry can be at Level 3 (Supervised) while AP invoice matching is at Level 1 (Assisted).
One workflow at every level
Section titled “One workflow at every level”The example is sales order entry: a customer emails a purchase order, and it has to become a sales order in your ERP.
Level 0 (Recorded)
Section titled “Level 0 (Recorded)”The order desk keys orders into a screen that records every field and every correction.
No agent is involved yet. Our forward-deployed engineers build the screen with the order desk, and the point of this level is the record it keeps. It shows what a correct order looks like for each customer, where the corrections happen and how long an order takes. An agent is later measured against that record.
Level 1 (Assisted)
Section titled “Level 1 (Assisted)”An agent reads the emailed purchase order and drafts the order. The order desk checks it and keys it.
The person still does the work. The agent saves them the reading and the looking up. Our engineers count each difference between the draft and what was keyed.
Level 2 (Prepared)
Section titled “Level 2 (Prepared)”The agent builds the complete order. A person reviews it and approves it.
Every order gets its own approval, and nothing is written to the ERP without one. The order desk’s work shifts from keying to checking.
Level 3 (Supervised)
Section titled “Level 3 (Supervised)”The agent enters orders that match the price list and the credit limit. Mismatches go to the order desk.
So does anything else outside the agent’s limits, such as an order from a customer who is not on its list. The order desk handles these exceptions and spot-checks a sample of the orders the agent entered on its own.
Level 4 (Autonomous)
Section titled “Level 4 (Autonomous)”The agent owns order entry. The order desk sets the rules and reviews a sample.
People no longer work the order queue day to day. They decide the policy the agent follows and audit what it did. They still receive the orders the policy reserves for a person.
Moving up and down
Section titled “Moving up and down” up: one level at a time, and only after a promotion review ---------------------------------------------------------->
Level 0 Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Recorded Assisted Prepared Supervised Autonomous
<---------------------------------------------------------- down: a level at once, by the workflow owner- Start at the bottom. A workflow typically starts at Level 0, and an agent first appears at Level 1.
- Up one level at a time. A workflow never skips a level.
- Only after a promotion review. The review checks four things: measured accuracy on real work against a threshold set in advance, the cost of a wrong action, that every action is logged and reversible, and sign-off by the workflow owner. Promotion reviews covers each one.
- Thresholds come first. They are set for each workflow with the workflow owner and written down before a level starts. We publish no threshold figures, because a threshold only means something for one workflow at one company.
- Down needs no review. Moving a workflow down is the workflow owner’s decision alone. It takes no review and no meeting. Moving back up takes a promotion review again.
What stays the same at every level
Section titled “What stays the same at every level”Our engineers build every agent with limits: amounts, customer and supplier lists, time windows. They also give it only the access its workflow needs, an audit trail of every action and a stop switch. The audit trail and the stop switch come from our reusable tooling. The limits are written for your workflow.
The emergency stop on a machine is a fair comparison. It is fitted on the day the machine is installed, not after something has gone wrong. Guardrails and limits covers how each of these works.
Where the ladder stops
Section titled “Where the ladder stops”- Not every workflow should reach Level 4. Some stay at Level 2 or 3 for good, and that is a fine result. A workflow where one wrong action is expensive or hard to put right is a good candidate to stay where a person approves every transaction. Each workflow playbook says how far that workflow should go.
- The ladder applies to fully digital work. That means work whose inputs and outputs are all digital, such as emails, documents and ERP transactions. Agents do not do physical work and do not operate machinery.